Thor Movie Review

I’ve waited a quarter of a century to see Thor on the big screen.  The God of Thunder was my first favorite superhero.  He is the character that got me into comics.  His tale is the one that planted the seeds of interest for the myths and legends of Gods and Goddesses long gone within my mind and imagination.  It’s been a long time coming for me to see him in all his live action glory.

Thor Movie Review

Before you ask, yes, I have a man crush on the character of Thor.  While Superman was the epitome of what my father’s generation would have wanted to be as men, Thor was that to me.  He is strong, brash, and bold.  He’s fearless and a leader of men.  I can point out specific moments in the comics I’ve read over the years that just thinking about them sends tingles down my spine because it meant Thor was going to do something so badass it had the power to make you faint in a total nerdgasm.

So, after twenty-five years of waiting for this moment, it has come…  Thor has been turned into a movie star.  I don’t think I could possibly have expected more, nor can I say I have a single disappointing thing to say about the movie.  As I review this movie, I will be mindful of those who cannot see the movie yet and try to go light on spoilers.  So, consider that your warning.

In the first few moments, after the opening credits, we learn of a great war that took place many centuries ago.  The dread Frost Giants were hoping to unleash a terrible Winter on Midgard (Earth) that would have plunged the entire world into another Ice Age.  Midgard would be protected by a warrior race of noble men – the Asgardians.  Their king, Odin unleashed a fury on the Frost Giants that drove them all the way back to their realm.  In their defeat, a truce was forged that kept the Frost Giants stuck in their realm without a casket containing their power.  Meanwhile, the Asgardians would never again tread into their world or bother them again.

On a day that would have seen Thor be crowned as the ruler of Asgard, Frost Giants break into Odin’s trophy room.  They nearly steal their power back but are met by the Destroyer who quickly puts an end to the shenanigans.  Enraged that his day was ruined, Thor devises a plan to strike back at the Frost Giants.  He’s accompanied by Sif, Loki, and the Warriors Three (Fendral, Hogun, and Volstagg).  After showing off what exactly he and Mjolnir can do, Odin comes to collect his trespassing followers.  Disappointed in what Thor has done to break the peace, Odin strips his firstborn son of his power and casts him out to Earth.

Most of my review will cover his time on Earth because that’s the real focal point of the entire story takes place, but let me just say Thor meets up with astro-physicist Jane Foster, her mentor, and a grad student who help him on his journey of self discovery.  Meanwhile, in Asgard, Odin has fallen into the Odinsleep, leaving Loki as the interim ruler.  Realizing much of what has happened has been the machinations of his step-brother, Thor eventually returns to Asgard to put an end to Loki’s tricks and schemes.

A lot of this movie revolves around the character of Thor.  I mean, I guess you could say, “Well, duh…  His name is the name of the whole movie!”  However, this Thor is not a mature, tempered man.  He’s kind of a brat and very cocksure.  Chris Hemsworth (who most American audiences would recognize as Captain Kirk’s father in the opening scene of 2009′s Star Trek) turns in a really nice performance.  First of all, you have to believe that he is a God.  His physique and demeanor pulls that off pretty well.  Next, you have to believe that he’s about as tough of a warrior as you’ll ever see.  In several instances, you get that.  Most importantly, though, you have to see him grow from where he began as an “action first” kind of man child, to a selfless and caring hero.

This is the type of characterization that you don’t often see in comic book movies.  You get it in spades in the original media, but the average moviegoer doesn’t get that luxury of years and years of character building and study.  Some could wonder exactly why Superman has to be a good man.  He has all this power, and he can do so much, but his biological father told him he would be these people’s savior.  He had a good, honest, and humble upbringing with the Kents, but it takes a man of unusual character to stick to his personal ethics and morals.  It’s such an unusual character that it can’t really be explored in a couple hours.  Why does Peter Parker have to give up his original motivations of using his power to gain riches as a celebrity?  What was it about his Uncle Ben that made him the person he is?  In any of his movies, is Batman really a “good” guy, or just someone who uses vigilante justice as a way to satisfy his need to dish out anger for what happened to him as a boy?  Is Tony Stark more interested in being a true, honest-to-God hero or is a big part of his Iron Man persona used to make money and be in the papers?  We could argue these points until the cows come home, but Thor takes the idea of what it means to be a hero with immense power, and a leader, to a whole different level.

Thor’s arrogance and temperament puts everything he should hold dear in question and danger.  Everything he ever had and anyone he ever loved could fall victim to the consequences of his own actions and selfishness.  Odin teaches him a lesson by stripping him of his power and forcing him to become worthy of it again.  While banished and living among them as one of them, Thor can see what the strengths and frailties of humans are and what they are capable of as a race.  It’s through his protection of them and sacrifice that grants him his rightful powers again.  He’s forever changed because of these experiences and learns the lesson Odin needed him to understand.  This is Hemsworth’s chance to really shine as an actor.  He’s not exactly a selfish God who instantly turns into a selfless man.  He grows into this and Hemsworth’s performance makes you believe this.

Next you have Loki, played by Tom Hiddleston.  Here’s a guy who is completely new to American audiences and has a massive load to carry as the single most important villain in Thor’s history.  Hiddleston plays Loki extremely well.  He kinda looks like a weaselly guy and that’s exactly what Loki is.  He’s one who can talk his way into and out of anything, but isn’t likely going to stand and fight when it’s most important, unless it’s for his own needs.  What’s interesting about Loki is how low key the character is.  All of his plans and machinations are never charted out for the audience.  Knowing everything there is to know about the character, I knew I couldn’t trust anything that came rolling off the serpent’s tongue.  However, I can say that the way Hiddleston delivers his lines and much of what he says can lead anyone to stop and think if he’s actually telling the truth.  Of all the characters in this movie, I think Loki was by far and away the best written and it was truly delightful seeing his character play out as the main villain.

As far as the rest of the cast goes, they are serviceable to the movie.  I think most of them could be interchanged with just about anyone to the exception of Anthony Hopkins as Odin.  When he was cast way back when, I honestly had the same “Yup, that’s perfect…” thoughts run through my head as I did when Patrick Stewart took the Professor X role.  I’m not sure anyone else could play that role or give it as much weight as Hopkins.  The supporting cast, while interchangeable, was still very solid and fun to watch.  I think of all the supporting cast, my favorite was Idris Elba as Heimdall.  I don’t care who plays what role or what race the actors are compared to the race of the original character.  If you can pull it off, I’m on your side.  Idris Elba more than easily pulled off Heimdall.  He acted and spoke how I expected that character to.  Every single moment Heimdall was on screen, I was glued to him.

When it comes to the action of the movie, Thor is full of awesome moments.  The very first time Thor uses Mjolnir in battle against the frost giants, I was able to check off everything I ever wanted to see the enchanted Uru hammer do.  He threw it, and it came back to him.  He pummeled Frost Giant heads with it.  He spun it around and used that action in a number of ways I didn’t even expect.  And, most importantly, he FLEW with it.  Each of the action sequences were simply damn cool.  Whether it was the hand to hand combat against S.H.I.E.L.D. agents guarding Mjolnir, the first battle with the Frost Giants, or the final showdown with Loki, there was a lot of epicness to it.

Now, if you’ve gotten this far, you may want to stop, now.  I’ve got a list of five things to keep your eyes peeled for in the movie.  A few of them are going to be slightly bigger spoilers, so here’s your last chance…

1.  A sign for a vacation spot using the phrase “Journey Into Mystery…”

2.  Odin’s enchantment on Mjolnir takes a specific three-point design that, very recently, adorns comics tying into Fear Itself

3.  Just before the end of the credits look for a message awesomely similar to what you see at the end of James Bond movies

4.  When Thor’s running wild through S.H.I.E.L.D. agents to get Mjolnir back, a certain archer is called in to take him down if necessary

5.  STAY TO THE END OF THE CREDITS!!!  The now traditional scene following the movie gives us a big hint as to what the Avengers will need to be assembled against…  The only hint I can give is to say it is the, arguably, most powerful and dangerous item ever seen in the Marvel Universe

For some, Thor may disappoint those looking for a lot of fighting and action.  For fans of the character, you’ll like the movie immensely.  For people who just enjoy superhero movies, you’ll appreciate that the story takes a different angle and dives deeper into character development.  Me?  I couldn’t have been happier.

A COMIC BOOK BLOG RATING

Pros Cons
Hemsworth and Hiddleston own their roles in ways that drive the movie to new places for the genre. Fun action scenes. Mjolnir doing what we’ve always seen it do in comics and that is purely awesome. Some may not endear themselves to the more character driven story. Some may even be let down by the trade off leading to less action sequences.
Rating
95%

More Thor & Movies:

Where To Start Reading Thor

Thor in our Geek Life blog

The Mighty Thor #1 Review

Iron Man 2 Movie Review


Tags:

9 Comments

  1. Nick says:

    Thor is getting surprisingly good reviews. I can’t wait to see it.

  2. Richie says:

    I absolutely can’t wait to go see this movie tonight.  Thanks for the great review, I really prefer reviews from fellow fans of the God of Thunder.

  3. Johnny Hall says:

    I liked it.  I’m not a big Thor guy, but I thought the movie was done pretty well.  Stringer Bell (Idris Elba) and Titus Pullo (Ray Stevenson), I LOVED seeing these guys play Norse Gods, great casting choices.  The guy playing Loki killed it, and may have been my favorite character in the film.  Most times the villains of superhero movies chew scenery, not so for Hiddleston, and this may be credit to Branaugh and the screenwriters as well, but often Loki was just a lurker.  He was often framed off to the side, as much a surveyor of the action as part of it.  I LOVED that, and it felt true to his character.  And Hiddleston, he could’ve frothed at the mouth, but instead chose to slow burn.  Great job, can’t wait to see him in future installments (perhaps?)
    Hemsworth was good, too.  He had a lot of clunky, Viking-esque dialogue that, by my best estimation, could have been unintentionally comical in the hands of a lesser actor.  Though, if you’re going to give the man a beard, give him a real damned beard!
    Hopkins was ok.  He looks too old, I think.  He did fine, he’s a fantastic actor, so he could have played Thor and made it believable.
    The SHIELD bits were my favorite, and Clark Gregg is such a great, understated actor.  He knows how to find the subtle comedy in every one of his lines.
    Before I ramble on and ruin the whole movie, I’ll just say I liked it.  Good summer popcorn flick, a better lead in to the Avengers movie than Iron Man 2, and tons of great casting choices.

  4. Grizzleybruin says:

    Hey Geoff! I’m so glad you enjoyed the movie, i know how much you love Thor from your Geek life articles, and if MARVEL had let you down, i would’ve been very angry at them. But having just seen the movie, i know that your excitement over the finished product is very well deserved.
    I loved Hemsworth & Hiddleston. . . . . . i mean LOVED those guys! they played their roles of Thor & Loki as if they were performing hamlet in front of an audience of shakespeare enthusiasts.
    i would like to take a second to point out the validity/absurdity of 3 of the complaints i’ve been hearing about the movie. (MASSIVE SPOILERS AHEAD!)1) The first is that Thor undergoes his transformation too quickly. Having practically grown up as a spoiled brat, he finds his humanity almost over the course of a “Touched by an angel” episode . . . .personally, i consider this to be false. It wasn’t the TIME that he spent on earth that brought about the change, but the circumstances surrounding his banishment: he was no longer a god, Odin had died, his mother no longer wished to see him, and he was no longer worthy of Mjolinir’s power (my favorite scene in the movie BY FAR was when Loki came to tell thor that Odin was dead…….i mean, Thor looked absolutely crushed, and the fact that he thanked Loki for coming in person to tell him that no one in asgard ever wanted to see his ass again just showed how humble he had become at that point) 2) The fight between thor & destroyer was too short: This is becoming a sore topic for a lot of superhero flicks, the idea that the last fight was too short (mostly because building up to that point took so long) But it made perfect sense why Thor dispatched destroyer so quickly: He got Mjolinir back. . . . destroyer was never SUPPOSED to be able to stand up to Mjolinir, and the fact that Thor floated him up in the air and crushed him like some freakn’ fatality made the extent of his hammer’s power that much more evident. Plus, the fight between Loki & Thor was what Snyder needs to take notes on to make sure Supes & Zod really bring it next year.3) Lastly, there is one complaint that i wholeheartedly agree with: Thor & Jane did not “fall in love” based on what was shown……i mean, they really, REALLY liked each other, but the fact that it was implied that his love for her was SO strong that a) he sacrificed himself to destroyer to save her life and that b) by destroying the rainbow bridge, thus saving the frost giants at the cost of never seeing Jane again, Odin was soooo touched that he woke up from odinsleep……eh, that’s more Lois & Clark soulmate love than Thor & Jane crush. . . . and the more they implied the two were pinning for each other at the end of the movie just made it look like they were showing the conclusion of some other love story.
    STILL: Brilliant film, great action, very smart comedy, amazing drama, VERY badass/relatable villain, total justice done to mythic/comicbook elements . . . definitely worthy of multiple viewings

    • Geoff Arbuckle says:

      Thanks so much for chiming in Grizzley! I’m glad you liked the movie too. I see the whole Thor/Jane thing as something that she was more a part of a very important moment for Thor and his gratitude toward her turned to endearment. Some may just say I’m making excuses, but hey… They only had 2 hours to work with. :)

  5. Wayland says:

    I, and everyone I saw it with, loved it. A great comic book movie, and a pretty good movie in general. Even the small bits, like the Warriors Three and Hawkeye, were very well done.

  6. PookDogg says:

    I really like the movie… I was suprised that there was no Stan Lee cameo though… I must’ve missed it if he was in it though. The scene where Loki tried to lift Mjolinir I thought was brilliant, as in the comics Loki has always pined for Mjolnir. I loved seeing the Infinety Guantlet in Odin’s Vault, I thought The Destroyer was awesome, looked exactly like I always hoped that it would. Really liked the understated feelings between Jane & Thor, that they didn’t fall “lois & clark head over heels” was great becuase they didn’t have the time to. So many things to like about the movie… can’t really think of any real complaints, thought Helmdall was great & really liked the warriors 3 as well. Only thing was that there was no Balder, when they were boys it only showed the 2 boys & there was never any mention of Balder throughout the movie… so when Loki got the throne through default I was like hey where is Balder… either way great movie & loved the scene after the credits.

    • Geoff Arbuckle says:

      Thanks for the comment! Actually Stan Lee was in the movie. His cameo was the guy in the truck who tried to pull Mjolnir from the crater, but lost his truck bed.

Author:

visit my website

I'm a lifelong geek. I don't hide it. I don't deny it. My true geek love is comics. I love reading them and discussing them. I am definitely much more a Marvel guy than DC, especially when it comes to my favorite, The Avengers. Questions? Comments? Email me at geoff@acomicbookblog.com